It’s Not About the Nail – It’s Not, It’s About A Man’s Need To Solve Her Problems

438454918_640

If you haven’t had a chance to see the Vimeo clip, “It’s not about the nail,” you’d be best to do that at your earliest convenience. I’ve watched it several times, each time I share it with someone I give it another view. It’s a short clip that basically focuses on, “I don’t want you to fix it. I just want you to listen.” While most men watched this video and thought to themselves, “So it’s not just me?!” They neglected to realize that even though the nail is clearly the problem, it’s not actually how we want that situation to pan out in our relationships.

I’ll be honest, while men are thinking this is a small victory for them, it actually exposes a flaw in our line of thinking. Over drinks Wednesday night I joked with a friend, “The funny thing about it is that while most men are thinking ‘Geez just take the nail out’ that’s not really what he wants to happen.”

Take for example, if his girlfriend comes home and says, “You remember how I was telling you I had those headaches? Well, I figured out what it was and it was a nail in my head. I took it out on the way home and I feel much better now.” Of course he may be happy that she’s no longer turning down sex or dishes because she has a headache, but he feels a little inadequate.

Have you ever heard men complain that they don’t want to feel that their girlfriend is needy, but they want to feel needed? Men complain about independent women because they start to feel that if a woman doesn’t need them, then why have them around.

Ideally what the man wants to do is to solve the problem. A man wants to feel like he was presented with a problem, he diagnosed and treated the problem and now everything is fine thanks to him. Don’t believe me, test him. (No, don’t really test him. That’s a figure of speech.) Continuously, solve your own problems. At times, don’t even mention that there was a problem until after the problem was fixed. If he’s any type of real man, he’ll start to get agitated. He’ll start to profess the things he expects to be responsible for doing.

And no, this isn’t a post about how men have some superiority complex or they need to feel like all women are under their power and control. It’s just about how men are wired. They want to be needed. They want to know they’ve got some roles in this whole thing that only they can fill. I look back at all my relationships and how many times I’ve said, “I expect you to control the things you can control and at least contain the things you can’t until we can get them under control.” That’s my definition between the difference between needy and interdependency.

And no matter how confusing this next part may be here’s the whole post in summary:

“I would like you to be able to take care of things like issues on your job, because there’s nothing I can do about that and you should know the difference between the things you can control and things you have to suck up. Your personal bills that are not mutual bills, I’d like you to pay them and never complain about them or ask what I think you should do about your bills or debt (that does not affect me). However, although you may be able to carry your groceries home, kill insects around the house, or put together furniture – NEVER do those things, that’s my job. Those things are clearly out of your control.”

Cheers.

Dr. J

From Our Partners

  • amicus82

    DRJ- I think your list of what makes a guy feel needed is good for a couple that's newly committed to each other. As a relationship develops however I think a man will need to be progressively more *willing* to carry his woman's personal burdens out of love for her and she will need to learn more and more to trust him enough to let go and let him come through for her. And vice versa.

    If these two things don't develop (love & trust), I think the relationship will stall and turn into a business with benefits relationship.

    IMO, the reason (1) men are wired with the desire to be needed & respected and (2) woman are wired with the desire to be loved & supported is so that upon making a connection the two will instinctively start the love/trust cycle that will eventually lead to true intimacy & romantic fulfillment. #awww
    My recent post Why Women Want

    • cynicaloptmst81

      LMBO @ #awwwww!

      But, I completely agree with you! :-)

  • http://whatyouallow.com/ Wildflower

    I agree with the whole leaving your drama at home. My mom use to come home complaining every day about her co workers. I was sick of hearing it so I know my dad wanted to blow his brains out.

    At the end of the day your partner should be your counselor, handyman, friend, etc but it should be done in moderation. No wants wants to be emotionally drained every time they see your pretty little face.

    My recent post Dont Believe The Hype, Interracial Relationships

  • Animate

    Man this is one of those learned things. There are so many times I want to "fix" issues my wife brings up but I just sit there and nod. I'm big on not adding unnecessary stress on your life and I can't for the life of me understand why some people just want to talk about what is causing the issue instead of wanting a resolution.
    My recent post The most powerful scene I've ever seen in a video game

  • Streetz

    I think you have a point, bt my thing is that we like to solve problems especially when they are bltently easy in our face. Whaen you are with someone, all problems wont be able to be solved by individuals, the important ones will need collaboration and thats where men can get that need feel you speak about.

    Sometimes it IS just the effing nail tho!

  • Lay

    I don’t necessarily want to be needed. I would prefer to be wanted. I fear that sometimes a woman could stay with me because I fulfill a need, or a set of needs; but what happens when her needs change? If she desires you, and not what you provide for her, I think the relationship has a better chance.